Score: 7

"Hah! very good."

submission: unlikely departures

date: January 14, 2003

I think we all tend to cringe when we hear "first animation," but this wasnt crap... actually pretty funny.

Score: 6

"Interesting"

submission: ®@ÑÐØm ½

date: January 13, 2003

Personally, I liked the whole 'random' plot.. sure the osama thing is overdone, but overall it was a nice movie.

altho we should be bombing that craphole england instead of a desert.

Score: 2

"kinda boring."

submission: N'SINK

date: January 12, 2003

sorry, but simply putting images to sound doesnt cut it.

Score: 6

"best one of the bunch so far."

submission: Robotech Director's Cut 2

date: January 12, 2003

Man, you gotta make more of these...

Score: 6

"A good series"

submission: The ROBOTECH movie part 2

date: January 11, 2003

I've seen most of your early stuff and I can say that I definately see a lot of improvement from your first attempts. The artwork is getting better, and I kinda like the mix of 3d cell shade renders, and traditional animation.

I think the one thing that stands out in your movies is that you seem to have an eye for creating good action sequences.

Try to work on keeping the animation as smooth as possible.

Score: 3

"Too close to dbz"

submission: Fight Tribute/help

date: October 20, 2002

The fighting style shown is way too close to DBZ. Not that that's really a bad thing, it just would be nice to see a more original fighting style

Score: 6

"great concept"

submission: Madness Combat

date: July 31, 2002

Hah, that was one of the funniest things on NG for a long time.

Just the artwork and the music... perfect match... great job on a wonderful concept.

Score: 4

"contra was awesome..."

submission: Contra Parody

date: June 2, 2002

hah, great parody... but you forgot to add the necessesary 99 lives code.

Score: 3

"Enjoy kids...."

submission: Tap Water

date: October 9, 2001

This was produced a long while ago by Xelger and Myself under the Thorax Entertainment label.... yeah perhaps the animation is great yet, but it will get better.

Score: 3

"Redundant."

submission: WTC Tribute

date: September 21, 2001

Ive said it before in other reviews of "wtc tribues"... the bulk of this movie was mindless, spoon-fed thought provided by the mass media on a daily basis... Dont get me wrong, I think its great that you pay tribute to the victims and so forth...but its still redundant

As for the movie itself, It wasnt all that great...tweening pictures and text... Im sorry, but on the artistic level (and im not talking about entertainment value) I dont think this movie is really that original in that it shares the same unoriginal thoughts that have been pounded into our heads by tv and radio over the last week and a half. Would have been better if it had something "new"